Wednesday, October 22, 2008

Dion like Dinner - The long farewell to a dismay failure

It can be said that yesterday's news conference marked the departure of an honest man. It can also be said that yesterday's news conference ushered in additional months of ineffective and delusional leadership by a leader who has lost the "moral authority" to lead the Liberal caucus.

I am blogging about this now as it took me a few hours to calm down after all the condescending BS that came from Mr. Dion's mouth, and of course other prominent Liberals.

Mr. Dion is delusional if he is pinning most of the blame on the Conservative's superior financial position. Mr. Dion is clearly not accepting blame for his historic defeat, even in his final weeks and months as leader of the Liberal Party of Canada he is not acting like a leader, no, he is acting like a Liberal. Defuse, deflect, and blame others.

At the end of the day, it is Mr. Dion's fault they lost the election:
  1. Mr. Dion failed to ignite the grassroots to support him, or the Liberal party, both in volunteers, and in donations;
  2. Mr. Dion failed to reform the Liberal party's donation strategy and bring it into the 21st century;
  3. Mr. Dion failed to unify the party, and bring in seasoned help from accomplished Liberal party operatives, instead relying on incompetent and unpopular supporters;
  4. Mr. Dion failed to listen to advice given by his strategists and campaign teams;
  5. Mr. Dion failed to create a compelling and moderate platform, instead, hitching the entire success and failure of the campaign on an unpopular wealth redistribution scheme he liked to call the "Green Shift"
  6. Mr. Dion failed to have the courage of his convictions in the promotion of his "Green Shift", instead burying it and not discussing it when he realized it wasn't going to sell;
  7. Most importantly, Mr. Dion failed to inspire Canadians to rally behind him, instead, he had to rely on his team to turn Liberal fortunes around. The Liberal vote has declined for 3 straight elections.
Mr. Dion has failed to take the blame, and instead blamed others. He considers his campaign performance good. I don't know what is in his koolaid.

Mr. Dion and other Liberals blame the Conservative advertising machine, instead of their policies, and their performance. He basically called Canadian's stupid, by saying that Canadians were too stupid to see through the Conservative "propaganda", he claims the "Green Shift" was an income tax cut, not a carbon tax.

When answering questions after his statement he claims his government would have been much better, and that in democracy you don't have to agree with the people, just accept their judgment. Again, he basically calls Canadians stupid. He also again links the Conservatives with the evil Americans and Australians.

I am sure the real motive behind Stephane Dion's decision to remain as party leader is a chance to have a do over at leading the Liberal's in another election. He is hoping the Government falls before the next leader is chosen, even though his image is "cemented" in the minds of Canadians.

Mr. Dion will be an ineffective leader of the opposition as he is a lame duck, and his best MPs will be crisscrossing the country on their own leadership tours. Be prepared for lots of Liberal MPs to come down with the democratic flu.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

By placing blame on everything except their own deficiencies, it is obvious that the Liberals don't want to take a good honest look at their own issues, and do what might be painfully necessary to turn things around for themselves.

They are having a very tough time keeping things on an even keel within their own Party. And they think they should become the government? Maybe they should start doing their jobs as the official Opposition first. 43 times they failed to do so, sacrificing their so-called principles and beliefs that were supposed to be at the core of their party's values. Now with an election just finished, can you see them being able to oppose the Government and change that trend when they are in a worse position than before?

Anonymous said...

Dion, his candidates and their web site had so many chances to explain the Green Shift and they couldn't do it properly or in depth.

I believe he is staying on for the extra money as Leader of the Opposition.

Anonymous said...

According to the Vancouver Sun, it would look like his speech was possibly written by this guy:

(`)
Dion's a footnote now in the bloody remaking of the Liberal Party of Canada. Marissen picked the wrong man.

That's not quite the way he sees it. At least not yet. The campaign's still too fresh.

His anger at the Conservatives, and their Karl Rove-style tactics of pooping puffins and deeply personal attack ads, has settled in deep and is palpable.

"I don't mind going on record as saying this was a case of character assassination," says Marissen, sipping his drink a few hours after his leader had called it quits on Monday.

"That's what happened to Stephane Dion, pure and simple."

Later, he BlackBerrys over an e-mail, a more carefully considered quote:

"Why he [Dion] lost -- his idealism. He felt that he must focus on proposing and explaining a complex plan to govern, rather than setting his sights on tearing the current government down.

"That clearly doesn't work. He is very tough -- but he's not a back-alley street fighter. He is a decent and honest man."

So this is Marissen's post-campaign analysis: An honourable idealist was beaten by political thuggery from the right.

(`)